MetsXMFanZone

Home / Blog

Mets News

Cohen Made the Trip. Inside the Mets' Sit-Down With Tarik Skubal and What Comes Next

Cohen Made the Trip. Inside the Mets' Sit-Down With Tarik Skubal and What Comes Next

Steve Cohen and David Stearns met Tarik Skubal in person on Nov. 16, and early reports say it went very well. Here is what we know, what we don't, and where the Mets can beat the Dodgers.

For two weeks we have been talking about Tarik Skubal and the Mets in the future tense. As of Monday, it is the present tense. The Mets sat down face to face with the best pitcher on the free agent market in Southern California on November 16, and the early word coming out of the room is good. Before we get carried away, here is what we actually know as of Wednesday, November 18, what we do not know, and why the next ten days matter more than anything that happened in that room.

Who was there, and what came out of it

Jon Heyman of the New York Post broke the news of the in-person meeting, and SNY's Chelsea Janes reported that the Mets sent their two biggest guns: owner Steve Cohen and president of baseball operations David Stearns. That detail matters. When the owner gets on a plane himself, it tells the player this is not a courtesy call.

Heyman's follow-up was that the meeting "went very well," with both sides reportedly coming away pleased. He was also careful to add that it is hard to know how much that means, and it is not clear whether the Mets put an offer on the table. That is the honest framing, and I am going to stick to it. Every team says its meeting went well. Nobody leaks that the coffee was cold and the pitch fell flat.

The Mets went first. That cuts both ways.

Skubal and his agent, Scott Boras, are packing a whole tour into one week. The Associated Press reported he would meet with six teams. The ones that have been named so far are the Mets, Dodgers, Padres and Blue Jays, and the other two have not been identified. The Mets appear to have been the first stop.

Going first is good for setting the tone. Cohen and Stearns got to frame the conversation before anyone else did, and every team after them has to answer whatever they put out there. The downside is just as real. The Dodgers, who traded for Skubal in August and watched him pitch them into October, may get the last word. Being the incumbent and the last meeting on the calendar is a strong position. Ask anyone who remembers how the Yamamoto chase ended.

The one gap the Mets can exploit

Here is the piece of reporting I find most interesting. Skubal reportedly wants a long-term deal with whoever he signs with, and the Dodgers have reportedly been leaning toward something shorter. Los Angeles has been stingy about long commitments to pitchers, with Yamamoto as the big exception. The Dodgers can match almost anyone on dollars. Length is a different conversation.

If that gap is real, it is exactly where Cohen can win this. The record for a pitcher is Yamamoto's 12-year, $325 million deal, and plenty of people expect Skubal to pass it. The Mets do not need to win on the annual salary alone. They need to give Skubal the years and the security he is reportedly asking for, at a number that makes the Dodgers blink. Owners who can guarantee money a decade out are not common, and Cohen is one of them.

Why it has to happen fast

The collective bargaining agreement expires at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 1, and almost everyone expects the owners to lock the players out right away. Once that happens, signings freeze. Reports say Skubal wants his deal done before then, and that is a much faster timeline than Boras usually runs with his top clients, who are known for waiting the market out. One report gave Skubal roughly a week after these meetings to decide whether he needs more time.

So in practical terms, this is a two-week sprint. If the Mets left that room feeling good, the next move is a number, and it probably needs to come soon.

What he would mean for this rotation

Skubal went 12-7 with a 2.72 ERA and 186 strikeouts last year between Detroit and Los Angeles, and that was his "down" season, interrupted by an injury and a midseason trade. Put him in front of Nolan McLean, who threw 179 2/3 innings with a 3.16 ERA and 194 strikeouts, and the Mets suddenly have a top two that can match up with anybody in the National League.

Behind them it gets thinner. Sean Manaea is owed $25 million in 2027, Christian Scott and Zac Thornton are young arms who will get chances, and free agents like Clay Holmes and Michael King have been connected to the Mets as possible middle-of-the-rotation adds. Without Skubal, that group needs two or three more starters to feel safe. With him, everyone slides down a spot into a role that fits them better. One signing changes how the whole staff is built.

My take

I came into this offseason skeptical. The Dodgers have beaten us to too many players for me to get excited over a rumor. But this is not a rumor anymore. Cohen and Stearns were in the room, the meeting went well by every account we have, and the Mets have a real angle with the contract length. That is more than we had on Monday morning.

I am not printing a jersey until the press conference. I am, though, officially done treating this like a long shot. Steve, you made the trip. Now make the offer he cannot walk away from. Let's go Mets.

Share Facebook X WhatsApp Email

Never miss a Mets moment

Live games, podcasts and breaking news, all in one place.