Mets News
Nobody's Untouchable, Says Stearns. Mets Fans Have Heard That Before, and the Name Is Crow-Armstrong
Stearns says no Mets prospect is completely untouchable. After the Pete Crow-Armstrong trade, here is what fans should demand before any deal gets done.
At the GM Meetings in Las Vegas, David Stearns was asked whether any Mets prospect is off the table this winter. His answer, reported by the New York Daily News, was that it would be "foolish for me to say that anyone is completely untouchable," though the club has players it thinks very highly of. It is a sensible thing for a baseball boss to say. It is also a sentence that makes Mets fans flinch, because we know exactly which trade it brings back to mind.
July 30, 2021. The Mets were 55-47 and four games up in the NL East when they sent Pete Crow-Armstrong, then their No. 5 prospect and coming off shoulder surgery, to the Cubs. Back came Javier Báez, Trevor Williams and cash. The Mets went on to finish 77-85 and missed the playoffs by a mile. Báez left as a free agent that winter.
Now look at what the Cubs got. Crow-Armstrong just put up 45 home runs and 41 steals, became the seventh member of the 40-40 club, and played what MLB.com calls the best center field in the game. He was an MVP finalist and has a six-year, $115 million extension in his pocket. Zack Scott, the executive who made that deal, has since admitted publicly that he misjudged the player and let the pressure of a pennant race pull him away from his usual discipline. Credit to him for owning it. It still stings.
Anthony Castrovince of MLB.com wrote this month that executives accept misses like this as part of the business. Fine. But accepting that misses happen is different from repeating the one that hurt most.
The lesson is not "never trade a prospect"
I am not asking the Mets to hoard every kid in the system. Prospects exist to be used, and plenty of them never become anything. The lesson from 2021 is about the price and the purpose. The Mets paid a premium asset for a short-term rental because the standings in July made them feel like they had to do something big. That is the part to avoid.
The good news is that the Mets' biggest target this winter does not cost a single prospect. Tarik Skubal is a free agent, and the Mets have a meeting with him in California this week. Over his last four seasons he is 50-20 with a 2.47 ERA and a 0.92 WHIP. SNY has reported that Steve Cohen wants him, and Stearns has never handed a pitcher a nine-figure deal, so this will test the front office as much as the bank account. If Skubal says yes, the rotation conversation changes, and nobody has to be traded for him.
Where the trade chips come in
Stearns has named first base and pitching as the priorities, and the bullpen needs bodies after the deadline sell-off of four veteran relievers. Right now the only locks in the 2027 rotation are Nolan McLean and Christian Scott. That is a lot of holes, and some of them will be filled by trade. MLB.com has floated names like Drew Rasmussen of the Rays and Reid Detmers of the Angels as possible targets. Trades usually do not heat up until late November or December, so there is time.
When they do, here is my checklist, as a fan who still remembers 2021:
First, buy years, not months. If a prospect goes out, a player with multiple seasons of control should come back. Second, do not trade from panic. The Mets finished 74-88 in 2026, so there is no pennant-race fever to cloud anybody's judgment this time. That is actually an advantage. Third, be honest about what the player is. Nobody knew PCA would be this, but the Mets did not need to find out by giving him away for a rental.
What to watch next
Keep an eye on the Skubal meeting, on whether the Mets land a first baseman through free agency or a trade, and on which names Stearns calls "very highly" regarded and keeps off the board. I like the plan to lean on free agency for the big swing. If the Mets do dip into the prospect pool, I want a return that is still helping us in 2029, not one that is gone by Christmas. We have already paid for that lesson once.


