MetsXMFanZone

Home / Blog

MetsXMFanZone News

The Mets Met With Alec Bohm. Here's Why First Base Is the Fit.

The Mets Met With Alec Bohm. Here's Why First Base Is the Fit.

The Mets sat down with free agent Alec Bohm at the GM meetings in Las Vegas. A fan's look at his splits, why first base is the target, the Polanco question, and what a deal could cost.

The GM meetings in Las Vegas usually give us a lot of smoke and not much fire, but one Mets name popped up this week that is worth talking about: Alec Bohm. The longtime Phillies corner infielder is a free agent for the first time, and on Thursday, Ken Rosenthal and Will Sammon of The Athletic reported that the Mets sat down with him in Vegas. SNY also reported a meeting with his representatives. The Yankees met with him too. So before anyone panics about a Phillie switching sides, let's slow down and look at what this actually means as of Friday, November 13. A meeting is a meeting. Nothing has been offered or agreed to.

Who Bohm is right now

Bohm turns 30 before Opening Day and spent all seven of his big league seasons in Philadelphia after going in the first round in 2018. His 2026 line looks ordinary on the surface: .249/.315/.383 with 15 homers and 88 RBI over 155 games. That number hides two very different seasons, though. He was ice cold through his first 35 games, hitting .159, and then from May 9 on he hit .274/.340/.433 with 14 homers and 73 RBI. He finished strong with an .808 OPS after the break and went 1.051 OPS in the Phillies' Wild Card loss.

The thing that jumps out for a Mets fan is the platoon split. For his career he has crushed left-handed pitching to the tune of .302/.351/.503, and he is a much more modest hitter against righties at .262/.315/.372. He has also been one of only seven right-handed hitters to drive in 85 or more runs in three of the last four seasons. He puts the ball in play and he drives in runs. He is not a slugger.

Why first base, not third

Here is the part that matters. Every report says the Mets' interest is about first base, and that makes sense for three reasons.

  • Third base is taken. Bo Bichette is there, and he is owed $42 million for 2027 with a player option at the same number for 2028.

  • Bohm's glove at third has been rough. Since 2020 he has the worst Defensive Runs Saved total of any third baseman in baseball, and Statcast had him at -8 Outs Above Average at the position this year. At first base, his numbers have been close to average for three years.

  • First base was a real hole. Mets first basemen put up a .667 OPS in 2026, third worst in the majors. Jared Young did a solid job against lefties, but he hit just .228 against right-handers.

The complication is Jorge Polanco, who is still owed $20 million for 2027. Bringing in Bohm would mean the front office is willing to move Polanco to a lesser role, or move him altogether. With Steve Cohen writing the checks, that money has never stopped this team before.

What would a deal look like?

The Phillies did not give Bohm a qualifying offer, which means signing him would not cost the Mets a draft pick. He made $10.2 million last season. Nobody has put out a hard projection yet, but the comparison being thrown around is Josh Bell's two-year, $30 million deal with Cleveland. One executive told MLB.com that Bohm could see multiyear offers at a lower salary than he wants, or he could take a one-year deal to build his value back up. Either way, this is not a mega contract. It is a mid-tier move.

The calendar matters here too. The labor deal expires December 1, and a lockout is widely expected. Teams that want to get business done are trying to do it in the next two and a half weeks, so if this has legs, we could know soon.

My take

I will admit it feels strange rooting for a guy I have spent years booing at Citizens Bank Park. But I like the idea more than I thought I would. Picture Bohm getting the bulk of the at-bats at first, with Young still in the mix against lefties. That is a cheap, smart way to turn one of the worst spots in our lineup into a strength, without giving up a pick or blocking anyone in the system.

What I do not want is Bohm as the headline move of the winter. After a 74-88 season, this team needs pitching and a real impact bat, and Bohm is neither. If he is the complementary piece that comes alongside something bigger, I am all in. If he is the big splash, I am going to be frustrated. Make the smart move, David Stearns, and then go make the big one. Let's go Mets.

Share Facebook X WhatsApp Email

Never miss a Mets moment

Live games, podcasts and breaking news, all in one place.